User blog comment:SBCA/Juan's Proposals 1: Promotion Policy/@comment-24412656-20161224132126

Seems alright in general but I do disagree with a few things here.


 * Rule #2 of General Requirements - I don't like the idea of tying someone's block log to their ability to apply for a position.
 * Rule #1 of Application Process - I think we should get rid of the request pages all together. I've noticed that far more people tend to vote when requests are done through blog posts rather than request pages. We should working to increase voter turn-out - requiring users to use the system that attracts the most amount of voters is a part of that.
 * Rule #5 of Application Process - It should be up to users themselves to decide whether they'd like to apply for a position or not. There shouldn't be such a thing as "nominating someone that's not you".